What’s your nonprofit’s magnetic personality?

Building Authentic Brand Values

Values are essential for authenticity and connection in your brand. Learn how to craft meaningful core values that resonate with your team and audience
Core value words and icons overlaid on a purple diamond icon, representing the different angles and perspectives nonprofits have to view their values through.

As humans, why do we need values?

My friend Adrienne Kmetz mentioned this question to me a few weeks ago and I haven’t been able to shake it!

Values are our way of associating ourselves with broader adjectives and actions that help someone understand who we are or brands we’re associated with.

Picture it as a roadmap to authenticity – a route that leads to a more fulfilling and purpose-driven existence. Values connect us to our deepest sense of self, but also can connect us with kindred spirits.

But no one goes around asking “what do you value?” to try to match up with someone. And very rarely can someone distill their entire values into just one word.

So how can we build brand values that actually mean something?

So many times we broaden our values to fit in with everyone rather than letting our ethos ring true – that’s how we end up with values that don’t mean anything at all.

At their best, values are our way of describing our convictions – they should cost us something. If I’m optimistic, then I have to believe the best about people even if someone is the worst. The cost is in alignment with who I am.

Brands tend to use multiple words to try to paint a picture of what we can’t see or hear and point people to the evidence of those values in our lives.

Why do we value values?

And here’s a hard truth. If you have over 5 core values listed on your website no one is remembering them, much less practicing them consistently.

It also tells me that there isn’t a clear focus, and there are probably a few values that can be merged or consolidated.

The most helpful values you can embrace for your organization are actionable and paint a picture of the type of person you want on your team.

Here’s a helpful exercise to make your core values more specific:

  1. Write down your core values.
  2. Group words or ideas that are similar to each other.
  3. From each value, list out similar words that help describe the value until you can’t think of any more synonyms.

Pro tip: Try not to use a thesaurus! Your brain will think of smaller words in plain language better than snazzy terms that are too abstract.

Here are some examples:

  • Human → Authentic → Approachable → Welcoming
  • Trustworthy → Dependable → Steady → Consistent
  • Professional → Expert → Experienced → Capable

These final words feel much more specific than the first ones, don’t they? They paint a clearer picture of the action behind the value rather than a general value that doesn’t mean much of anything.

Values are a way of finding our place in the world. But for your brand, values also set the tone for your culture. They provide a north star for your team to make aligned decisions and also inform how your brand should look and act in the world. Getting crystal clear on your values aligns all the other parts of your brand.

Related Resources

For more insights on nonprofit branding and values, explore these articles:

Needs, Not Wants: 9 Must-Haves for Nonprofit Branding

Needs, Not Wants: 9 Must-Haves for Nonprofit Branding

Understanding the ins and outs of branding can be overwhelming and it can be even more difficult to know which…
5 Tips for Building Brand Authenticity

5 Tips for Building Brand Authenticity

Authenticity— it can’t be bought, it’s difficult to define, and it can be hard to measure. And yet it is…
Radio Categories
Branding and marketing are often lumped together, but they serve two very different purposes. In this post, you’ll learn the real difference between branding and marketing, why the order matters, and how to set your organization up for more powerful, consistent, and aligned communications.
If talking about your nonprofit feels confusing or unclear, you’re not alone. The SPARK Strategy is a simple, powerful framework to help you confidently communicate your mission, connect with the right people, and inspire more support. In this post, I’ll walk you through exactly how it works and how to get started.
This post breaks down 5 smart strategies to help you build a great nonprofit website, guide visitors to action, and feel proud of how your nonprofit is being shared online.
Not sure when to refresh your nonprofit’s brand and website? In this post, I’m sharing the best (and worst!) times to rebrand plus how to plan around events, campaigns, and busy seasons without overwhelming your team.
If your nonprofit website feels outdated or isn’t converting visitors into donors, these 3 simple fixes can start turning it around. Learn how to turn your site into a fundraising asset today.
If your fundraising feels harder than it should, your brand might be quietly working against you. Watch this quick video to learn how the right brand can help more of the right donors find YOU instead of chasing them.
Branding and marketing are often lumped together, but they serve two very different purposes. In this post, you’ll learn the real difference between branding and marketing, why the order matters, and how to set your organization up for more powerful, consistent, and aligned communications.
If talking about your nonprofit feels confusing or unclear, you’re not alone. The SPARK Strategy is a simple, powerful framework to help you confidently communicate your mission, connect with the right people, and inspire more support. In this post, I’ll walk you through exactly how it works and how to get started.
This post breaks down 5 smart strategies to help you build a great nonprofit website, guide visitors to action, and feel proud of how your nonprofit is being shared online.
Not sure when to refresh your nonprofit’s brand and website? In this post, I’m sharing the best (and worst!) times to rebrand plus how to plan around events, campaigns, and busy seasons without overwhelming your team.
If your nonprofit website feels outdated or isn’t converting visitors into donors, these 3 simple fixes can start turning it around. Learn how to turn your site into a fundraising asset today.
If your fundraising feels harder than it should, your brand might be quietly working against you. Watch this quick video to learn how the right brand can help more of the right donors find YOU instead of chasing them.

Stay in the Loop

Get helpful insights, tips, and news delivered right to your inbox.