Brand Positioning for Nonprofits: 5 Keys to Differentiation and Growth
-
Lauren Atherton
Our human brain is incredibly good at identifying patterns and organizing information—it works like a giant filing system. We’re constantly sorting ideas, experiences, and thoughts into categories to make sense of the world around us.
This is why we’re so obsessed with “communicating clearly” or having a memorable visual brand—because we instinctively know that if your mission sticks in the minds of your supporters or connects with their hearts, they’ll be moved to give or volunteer.
If I were to ask you to name one nonprofit in the animal rights space, you’d probably come up with three. Or humanitarian aid, or environmental justice. While it’s easy to think these organizations “have just been around forever” or “have unlimited funds,” the truth is that they have a clear position in the market—and in that mental filing cabinet of people’s minds—including yours!
Brand positioning is something nonprofits rarely talk about, but if you have a mission statement, then chances are you have the start of a positioning statement. Positioning helps you create clarity in a crowded space, making it easier for people to understand your organization’s unique value.
I was reminded of this while reading Obviously Awesome by April Dunford (shoutout to Tim Sarrantonio for the recommendation!). April is the expert on positioning for product-based businesses, but I think her methods translate really well into the nonprofit sector.
Positioning is the strategy work your nonprofit does before fully committing to branding efforts. Often, nonprofit leaders want to jump straight into design updates, but I always recommend taking the time to make sure your foundations are set first. You may not know exactly who you are yet—and that’s okay!
However, one thing applies at every stage of your journey: brand positioning.
What is brand positioning?
April Dunford defines brand positioning as: “what market you intend to win and why you deserve to win it.” But translated for nonprofits, I see this as “what category you intend to lead and why you deserve to lead it.”
Every nonprofit organization aims to fix a problem or fulfill a need, and while many nonprofit leaders feel like they don’t exist in a single box—the problem you aim to fix does exist in a category or vertical in the minds of your supporters. Clean water, animal welfare, environmental justice, civil rights, mentorship, etc.
These are big spaces, right? In action, your nonprofit most likely solves one sliver of the problem, whether by geographic location or specialized solution. This is your unique expertise, or vertical and horizontal positioning as David C. Baker describes it in his book The Business of Expertise. Having “crosshairs” on both your vertical and horizontal positioning is the key to being seen as an expert in the minds of your supporters.
April defines 5 main components in positioning, but I’ve updated them for nonprofits:
- Alternatives: If your nonprofit didn’t exist, what would people do to solve this problem?
- Capabilities: How do you solve the problem in a way that other organizations do not?
- Impact: What value do your capabilities enable for who you serve?
- Supporters that Care: Who cares a heck of a lot about that impact?
- Category: What context makes the impact obvious to your ideal donors?
Here’s how it works together:
But isn’t a mission statement enough?
Almost every nonprofit has a mission and vision statement, but these statements don’t tell the whole (or accurate) story of your organization. Each statement plays a unique role in shaping your nonprofit’s identity and how it’s perceived. Here’s a quick breakdown:
- Mission Statement: Explains why your nonprofit exists and answers, “What problem are we solving, and by when?”
- Vision Statement: Describes the ideal future you’re working toward. It’s the big picture that inspires your long-term goals.
- Brand Positioning: This is where strategy comes into play. Brand positioning is your competitive advantage. It defines how you want to be perceived compared to other organizations with similar missions. It answers the question, “Why should donors, volunteers, and partners choose us right now?”
Positioning is something that’s talked about a lot in the for-profit sector and startups, but not very much in the nonprofit sector. But when you set up your nonprofit, you probably positioned yourself in the marketplace without really knowing that what you were doing was, in fact, positioning!
Why does positioning matter for nonprofits?
Many nonprofits don’t like to talk about “competition” and “winning” the market so let’s take a different spin on it. Think of your nonprofit being known for one thing and being surrounded by complementary organizations. Funders don’t come to you trying to get a whole list of problems solved, but they do know what you clearly stand for and you can happily send them to another organization if they’re not a good fit for you. There’s freedom in being specific and this also helps to eliminate mission drift and scope creep—you can focus on what you do best.
Here’s why positioning matters for nonprofits:
- Differentiation: Brand positioning allows you to carve out a distinct space for your organization. It helps clarify why people should support your nonprofit over others with similar missions.
- Persuasion: Positioning shapes how your nonprofit is understood by donors, volunteers, and partners. It communicates what sets you apart in a way that resonates with them.
- Evolution: Your brand positioning evolves as your organization grows. It’s not static—it adapts alongside your nonprofit’s programs and impact.
The truth is, your nonprofit is facing competition for dollars and recognition. Countless organizations work toward similar goals in the category—whether it’s fighting hunger, providing shelter, or advancing education. While your mission and vision guide your daily work, positioning helps your nonprofit provide a frame of reference for donors, signaling where you fit in so your approach can stand out.
Positioning sets the foundation for branding
Positioning is not just a strategy—it’s the foundation for your entire brand. It shapes how people perceive your organization by communicating what sets you apart from other nonprofits. Clear positioning helps you articulate your unique value in a way that resonates with your target audience—whether it’s donors, volunteers, beneficiaries, or partners.
Your positioning directly informs your branding. It influences everything from your messaging and visual identity to your outreach strategy. When your positioning is clear, your branding aligns with it, ensuring that every interaction with your nonprofit reinforces your unique value.
As your nonprofit grows, so does your brand positioning. It adapts as you evolve, ensuring your organization remains relevant and continues to attract the right supporters. Ultimately, having a clear brand position sets your nonprofit up for long-term success.
Greater impact starts by aligning your position
Positioning is foundational to your nonprofit’s long-term success, so it’s important to get clear on how your organization is currently positioning itself. It ensures that your audience understands what makes your organization unique and why they should get involved. While your mission and vision guide your work, positioning gives it clarity and direction.
The great news is that you can probably easily answer those five questions about your nonprofit! Maybe you’ve just never written it down or articulated it before. Positioning isn’t necessarily coming up with something new to define your nonprofit, but getting clear on what you’re already doing and known for in your category. Most likely, you’re doing better than you think and positioning can help you stay laser-focused on your mission!
By strategically positioning your nonprofit, you can attract the right supporters who believe in your mission and want to help you achieve your vision. Remember, positioning is about more than just standing out—it’s about ensuring your nonprofit thrives while staying true to its purpose.
Sources:
- Obviously Awesome by April Dunford
- The Business of Expertise by David C. Baker
- “An Introduction to Positioning” by April Dunford: https://www.aprildunford.com/post/an-introduction-to-positioning
Lauren Atherton
Discover your *magnetic* brand personality
Related Resources
Explore these additional resources for more info on how branding can help your nonprofit stand out from the noise:
Unlocking Your Nonprofit's Unique Reason to Give (URG)
Bringing Energy and Life to Your Nonprofit Brand
